In the 2014 Federal budget, the government announced that it would begin consultations aimed at removing the existing ECP rules and treat ECP as a new class of depreciable property, presumably, subject to the same rules that are currently used for depreciable assets.
The government stated that this change is intended to simplify and reduce the tax compliance costs for businesses. Although no proposed legislation has been released, we expect that any changes will eliminate an important tax deferral that a corporate vendor of ECP can currently realize in certain circumstances (particularly where goodwill is sold).
Under the existing rules, 50% of gains arising from the sale of goodwill by a Canadian Controlled Private Corporation (“CCPC”) is taxed as active business income ("ABI") to the CCPC. We expect that any new measures will likely cause the 50% taxable portion of such gains to be taxed as investment income, at a higher corporate tax rate than ABI for CCPC's. Since the difference in the tax rates between ABI and investment income is largely equalized once personal tax is paid on the distribution out of the CCPC, the potential increase in the effective corporate tax rate represents a lost deferral rather than an absolute tax cost.
For example, assume a CCPC sells goodwill, that has no cost base, for $10M. Under the current rules $5M of the gain would be subject to tax as active business income to the vendor, giving rise to $1.3M of tax at the corporate level (using BC rates). Under the anticipated rules $5M of the gain will likely be taxed as investment income to the vendor, giving rise to approximately $2.3M of tax at the corporate level.
In this example, the new ECP regime would eliminate a tax deferral of approximately $1M ($1.3M vs, $2.3M) which would otherwise be available to the corporation.
With potential changes to the taxation of ECP on the horizon, corporate vendors of goodwill may wish to seek tax advice with respect to how the anticipated new rules may apply to their situation.